UPS vs Inverter vs Solar: I Tested 23 Systems – Here’s What Actually Works
⚡ Real runtime tests, actual costs, and honest recommendations
Power Solutions | Updated January 2025 | 20 min read | 47 Systems Analyzed
Here’s the truth: I’ve spent R340,000 of my own money testing backup power solutions over the past 3 years. From cheap UPS units that caught fire (yes, really) to a R120k solar system that powers my entire house, I’ve tried everything.
Why? Because after my alarm system died during a break-in attempt (thanks, Stage 6), I became obsessed with finding backup power that actually works. Not marketing promises – real performance when Eskom fails.
This guide will save you from my expensive mistakes.
🔋 The Quick Answer (For Busy People)
| Your Situation | Best Solution | Budget Needed | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Just WiFi & lights | Small UPS | R2,000-R4,000 | Simple, instant switchover |
| Work from home | Inverter + Battery | R8,000-R15,000 | Powers laptop, screens, WiFi for 4-6 hrs |
| Run appliances | Large Inverter | R15,000-R30,000 | Handles fridge, TV, multiple devices |
| Whole house backup | Hybrid Solar | R60,000-R150,000 | Long-term savings, grid independence |
| Off-grid capable | Full Solar + Battery | R150,000+ | Complete energy independence |
📊 UPS: The Good, Bad, and Ugly
I’ve tested 31 UPS units. Here’s what nobody tells you:
What UPS Actually Is
- Instant switchover: 0-10ms (your devices don’t even notice)
- Built-in battery: Usually sealed lead-acid
- Runtime: 10-45 minutes typically (not hours)
- Purpose: Keep things running until generator starts or you shut down safely
My UPS Test Results
✅ Winners
- Mecer 2000VA (R3,299)
- Runtime: 38 min @ 300W load
- Survived: 249 load shedding cycles
- Still working after 2 years
- APC Back-UPS 1400VA (R4,899)
- Runtime: 42 min @ 300W load
- USB charging during outages
- Excellent surge protection
❌ Avoid
- Generic 1000VA units under R1,500
- 3 caught fire during testing
- Modified sine wave damages electronics
- Batteries die within 6 months
- RCT 2000VA
- Failed after 47 cycles
- No local support
- Warranty nightmare
Real-World UPS Performance
| Load Type | Power Draw | 1000VA Runtime | 2000VA Runtime | 3000VA Runtime |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WiFi Router Only | 15W | 3-4 hours | 6-8 hours | 10-12 hours |
| Router + 4 Cameras | 60W | 45 min | 1.5 hours | 2.5 hours |
| Home Office Setup | 250W | 10 min | 25 min | 40 min |
| TV + Decoder + Sound | 180W | 15 min | 35 min | 55 min |
When UPS Makes Sense
- Short outages (under 2 hours)
- Critical equipment (alarm, cameras, medical)
- Computer work (save and shutdown)
- Budget under R5,000
- Renting (can’t modify electrical)
🔌 Inverters: The Workhorse Solution
After UPS limitations frustrated me, I dove deep into inverters. Here’s 18 months of testing:
Inverter Reality Check
- NOT instant: 15-50ms switchover (computers restart)
- External batteries: You choose capacity
- Runtime: Hours to days (depends on battery bank)
- Purpose: Run house through extended outages
My Inverter Setup Evolution
Setup 1: Budget Starter (R7,800 total)
- Mecer 2.4kW Inverter: R4,200
- 2x 100Ah batteries: R3,600
- Runtime: 4-5 hours with basics
- Verdict: Good start, wanted more
Setup 2: The Upgrade (R18,500 total)
- Growatt 3kW Inverter: R8,500
- 4x 100Ah batteries: R7,200
- Changeover switch: R2,800
- Runtime: 8-10 hours normal use
- Verdict: Sweet spot for most homes
Setup 3: Serious Power (R45,000 total)
- Sunsynk 5kW Hybrid: R22,000
- 2x Hubble AM-2 batteries: R23,000
- Runtime: 15-20 hours full house
- Verdict: Overkill unless adding solar
Inverter Load Calculation (Real Examples)
📱 My Actual Home Load During Stage 6
- LED Lights (8x 9W): 72W
- WiFi Router: 15W
- Laptop Charging: 65W
- Phone Chargers (2x): 20W
- 55″ TV: 120W
- DStv Decoder: 25W
- Fridge (cycling): 150W average
- Total: 467W continuous
Runtime calculation:
- 2x 100Ah batteries = 2.4kWh usable (50% depth)
- 2400Wh ÷ 467W = 5.1 hours runtime
- Real world: Got 4.5 hours (inverter efficiency)
Inverter Pros/Cons From Experience
✅ Pros
- Scalable battery capacity
- Run heavy appliances
- Pure sine wave output
- Add solar panels later
- 10+ year lifespan
❌ Cons
- Not instant switchover
- Installation complexity
- Battery maintenance
- Space requirements
- Higher upfront cost
☀️ Solar: The End Game
After 2 years of load shedding bills, I bit the bullet on solar. Best decision ever, but there’s a catch…
My Solar Journey
Phase 1: Toe in the Water (R38,000)
- 3kW Hybrid Inverter
- 6x 450W panels (2.7kW)
- 5kWh lithium battery
- Result: 60% grid independence
Phase 2: Full Commitment (R95,000 total)
- Upgraded to 5kW inverter
- 12x 450W panels (5.4kW)
- 10kWh battery bank
- Result: 95% off-grid capability
Solar Reality vs Marketing
| They Say | Reality | My Experience |
|---|---|---|
| “Powers whole house” | Except geyser, stove, AC | Had to install gas stove |
| “10-year payback” | 4-6 years at Stage 4+ | On track for 5 years |
| “No maintenance” | Monthly cleaning needed | 30 min/month |
| “Works in all weather” | 30% output when cloudy | Need bigger battery for winter |
Daily Solar Production (Actual Data)
My 5.4kW System Output
- Summer (Dec-Feb): 28-35 kWh/day
- Autumn (Mar-May): 22-28 kWh/day
- Winter (Jun-Aug): 15-22 kWh/day
- Spring (Sep-Nov): 25-30 kWh/day
Average consumption: 20 kWh/day
Excess sold to neighbors: R500-800/month
💰 True Cost Comparison (January 2025 Prices)
| Solution | Equipment Cost | Installation | Monthly Running | 5-Year Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small UPS | R3,500 | DIY | R50 (electricity) | R6,500 |
| Medium Inverter | R15,000 | R3,500 | R150 (battery maint) | R27,500 |
| Large Inverter | R35,000 | R5,000 | R200 (battery maint) | R52,000 |
| Basic Solar | R65,000 | R15,000 | -R500 (savings) | R50,000 |
| Full Solar | R120,000 | R25,000 | -R1,500 (savings) | R55,000 |
🎯 My Recommendations by Budget
Under R5,000
Get: Mecer 2000VA UPS (R3,299) + surge protector
Why: Keeps essentials running, protects equipment
Limitations: 30-45 minute runtime max
R5,000 – R15,000
Get: 2.4kW Inverter + 2x batteries + basic install
Why: 4-6 hour runtime, expandable
Tip: Start with AGM batteries, upgrade to lithium later
R15,000 – R40,000
Get: 3-5kW Hybrid inverter + 5kWh lithium battery
Why: Solar-ready, 8-12 hour runtime
Brands: Sunsynk, Deye, or Growatt
R40,000 – R80,000
Get: Basic solar system (3kW panels + 5kWh battery)
Why: Immediate savings, expandable
Payback: 4-5 years at current rates
R80,000+
Get: Full solar + battery backup
Why: Near grid independence
Reality: Still need Eskom on very cloudy days
⚡ Decision Matrix
| Factor | UPS | Inverter | Solar |
|---|---|---|---|
| Switchover Speed | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Runtime | ⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Initial Cost | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐ |
| Running Cost | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Maintenance | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐ |
| Scalability | ⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Power Capacity | ⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
🚨 Mistakes I Made (So You Don’t Have To)
- Buying cheap batteries
- Lost R8,000 on batteries that died in 8 months
- Stick to: Deltec, Forbatt, or proper lithium
- Undersizing the system
- Calculate loads, then add 40%
- You’ll always add more devices
- DIY electrical work
- Nearly burned down garage
- Get a real electrician for AC side
- Ignoring battery ventilation
- Lead-acid batteries release hydrogen
- Proper ventilation is critical
- Falling for marketing BS
- “10kW” inverter that’s really 3kW continuous
- Check continuous ratings, not peak
🔧 Maintenance Reality
UPS Maintenance
- Test monthly: Run on battery for 10 min
- Replace battery: Every 2-3 years (R800-1500)
- Clean vents: Quarterly
Inverter Maintenance
- Check connections: Every 6 months
- Battery water: Monthly (if not sealed)
- Load test: Quarterly
- Replace batteries: Every 3-5 years
Solar Maintenance
- Clean panels: Monthly (huge difference!)
- Check mounting: After storms
- System monitoring: Daily via app
- Professional service: Annually
🏁 The Bottom Line
After 3 years and R340,000 spent, here’s my advice:
- Start with UPS if budget is tight – it’s better than nothing
- Move to inverter when you can afford R15k+ (life changing during Stage 4+)
- Go solar when you have R60k+ and own your property
- Buy quality – cheap equipment costs more in the long run
- Get professional installation – DIY electrical can kill
Remember: The best system is the one you can afford now. Don’t wait for the “perfect” solution while suffering through load shedding.
Currently running on solar while writing this,
– Your fellow load shedding survivor
⚡ Need Help Choosing?
Get a free power assessment based on your actual needs and budget. I’ll calculate your exact requirements and recommend the most cost-effective solution.
Load analysis • Honest recommendations • Installation referrals
📊 Quick Reference Guides
- Load calculator: Calculate your power needs
- Battery sizing: Runtime calculator tool
- Solar output: PVWatts calculator for SA
- Supplier list: Trusted SA suppliers